First impressions of The Sheep Detectives

The Sheep Detectives, like Paddington — and like Babe, that masterpiece by which all talking-animal movies are measured — delights me, makes me laugh, and meaningfully moves me to the edge of tears.

Filed under: The Sheep DetectivesKyle BaldaCraig MazinFilm ReviewOn Movies & MediaChristopher MillerPhil Lord
First impressions of The Sheep Detectives
George Hardy (Hugh Jackman) and his golden favorite, Lily (voiced by Julia Louis-Dreyfus). [Image: Amazon MGM Studios trailer]

In this review, I will do my very best to avoid flock-related puns. Let’s leave that to the Grandmaster of Puns, The New Yorker’s Justin Chang — some comments from him seem inevitable. (He’s got mutton better to do.)


Have you seen the trailer for The Sheep Detectives? If so, let me put your worries to rest. This movie rivals Paul King’s first Paddington as the family film with the most unfortunate trailer. The promos for both movies made me say, “Nope. Absolutely not.” The warm critical reception for both, then, made me repent of my hasty dismissal. I had to check them out for myself.

And lo . . . to my amazement, The Sheep Detectives, like Paddington — and like Babe, that George Miller’s 1995 masterpiece by which all talking-animal movies are measured — delighted me, made me laugh, and meaningfully moved me to the edge of tears. I wondered, as I emerged from the theater, if my face might be glowing from the joy of it all.

Am I overreacting? Am I just starved for escapism?

Mopple (Chris O’Dowd), Lily (Julia Louis-Dreyfus), and Sebastian (Bryan Cranston) in the Denbrook churchyard. [Image: Amazon MGM Studios trailer]
🎟️
Looking for the rest of this review? Join the large-hearted readers who support this work with a few dollars (or more). I am grateful for readers who enable me to highlight occasions of beauty, truth, love, and imagination in this troubled and troubling world.